Advertisement
Case Report| Volume 56, ISSUE 4, P420-423, June 2003

Use of the subcutaneously based nasolabial flap in lower eyelid reconstruction

      Abstract

      A 54-year-old male had a history of approximately 18 months, with a diagnostically proven squamous cell carcinoma of the lower left eyelid. The full-thickness subtotal defect was reconstructed with the Hughes procedure (tarsoconjunctival flap) combined with a subcutaneously based nasolabial flap for skin coverage. To our knowledge, the use of the subcutaneous based nasolabial flap in this context has not been described previously. Use of the nasolabial flap may be considered for eyelid reconstruction.

      Keywords

      Reconstruction of full-thickness eyelid defects has to provide a mobile lid with corneal protection, good aesthetic quality, and acceptable donor site morbidity.
      For this purpose, skin, support and conjunctiva must be reconstructed. We describe the use of the Hughes procedure
      • Hughes W.L
      A new method for rebuilding a lower eyelid. Report of a case.
      (tarsoconjunctival flap) in conjunction with a subcutaneous based nasolabial transposition flap. To our knowledge, the use of the subcutaneous based nasolabial flap in this context has not been described previously.

      1. Case report

      A 54-year-old male was booked for surgery after treatment by an ophthalmologist and a dermatologist. There was 18 months history of a diagnostically proven squamous cell carcinoma of the lower left eyelid. The recurrent carcinoma was infiltrating the tarsal plate but there were no signs of deep infiltration into the orbital cavity. The reconstructive procedure included a mucosal lining with the tarsoconjunctival flap (Hughes procedure), while the 38×30 mm2 skin defect was reconstructed using a subcutaneously based nasolabial flap. Frozen specimens sampling was obtained, to verify a microscopically complete resection. Three weeks later, the tarsoconjuntival flap was subsequently separated; care was taken to cover the lid margin with excess conjunctiva, in order to avoid hair growth towards the cornea (Fig. 1, Fig. 2, Fig. 3) . Three months postoperative clinical assessment revealed neither ectropion nor entropion (see Fig. 4(a) and (b)) .
      Figure thumbnail gr1
      Fig. 1The defect seen after frozen specimens sampling and excision including a subtotal resection of the lower eyelid, preserving the lacrimal duct medially. The skin defects measured 38 mm in wide and 30 mm in high.
      Figure thumbnail gr2
      Fig. 2Left lateral view: the inner lining and tarsal plate reconstructed with a tarsoconjunctival flap. The planned nasolabial flap has been drawn.
      Figure thumbnail gr3
      Fig. 3(A) The nasolabial flap has been dissected, on a subcutaneously pedicled. (B) The nasolabial flap has been transposed 90 degrees anticlockwise, and prepared for inset.
      Figure thumbnail gr4
      Fig. 4(A) One-month postoperative result: note the symmetry, and the redness of the conjunctival flap. (B) Lateral view: no excessive bulkiness of the nasolabial flap.

      2. Discussion

      Reconstruction of the eyelid with mucosal lining, support and cutaneous cover to achieve normal appearance and function, are still a challenge to the surgeon. Siegel
      • Siegel R.J
      Palatal grafts for eyelid reconstruction.
      described the use of a nasolabial flap to cover a shallow lower eyelid defect combined with a palatal mucosal graft. The flap pedicle includes the angular artery. In our reconstruction, the blood supply is derived from the infraorbital artery (IOA) and the anastomoses between the lateral nasal artery and branches of IOA.
      • Nakajima H
      • Imanishi N
      • Aiso S
      Facial artery in the upper lip and nose: anatomy and a clinical application.
      Although the flap has a random pattern of blood, it acts as an axial flap (perforator from the IOA), due to the extensive vascularisation of the face. In our case, the defect was extensive, including the orbicularis muscle together with a 38 mm wide and 30 mm high skin defect.
      Conventional techniques for the reconstruction of extensive lower eyelid defects include the use of nasal septal cartilage,
      • Mustarde J.C
      Problems in eyelid reconstruction.
      auricular cartilage,
      • Koshima I
      • Urushibara K
      • Okuyama H
      • Moriguchi T
      Ear helix flap for reconstruction of total loss of the upper eyelid.
      • Krastinova D
      • Franchi G
      • Kelly M.B
      • Chabolle F
      Rehabilitation of the paralysed or lax lower eyelid using a graft of conchal cartilage.
      hard palate mucosa
      • Nakajima T
      • Yoshimura Y
      One-stage reconstruction of full-thickness lower eyelid defects using a subcutaneous pedicle flap lined by a palatal mucosal graft.
      • Siegel R.J
      Palatal grafts for eyelid reconstruction.
      or other autologous grafts for replacement of the posterior lamella, combined with cheek rotation flap (Mustardé),
      • Mustardé J.C
      Major reconstruction of the eyelid: function and aesthetics considerations.
      bipedicled Musculocutaneous Tripier flap (Leon Tripier, first described in 1888), upper eyelid flap,
      • Porfiris E
      • Christopoulos A
      • Sandris P
      • Georgiou P
      • Ioannidis A
      • Popa C.V
      • Kalokerinos D
      Upper eyelid orbicularis oculi flap with tarsoconjunctival island for reconstruction of full-thickness lower lid defects.
      subcutaneous pedicled flap raised from the temporozygomatic area,
      • Nakajima T
      • Yoshimura Y
      One-stage reconstruction of full-thickness lower eyelid defects using a subcutaneous pedicle flap lined by a palatal mucosal graft.
      angular artery flap,
      • Furnas D.W
      • Furnas H
      Angular artery flap for total reconstruction of the lower eyelid.
      the mid-forehead or glabellar flap,
      • Dortzbach R.K
      • Hawes M.J
      Midline forehead flap in reconstructive procedures of the eyelids and exenterated socket.
      Tenzel's semicircle flap,
      • Tenzel R.R
      Eyelid reconstruction by the semicircle flap technique.
      Fricke flap or a full-thickness skin graft.
      By contrast, when compared with other mucosal grafts, e.g. the nasal septum, the hard palate mucosa is claimed to sustain the characteristics of conjunctiva and tarsus with lining and support.
      • Siegel R.J
      Palatal grafts for eyelid reconstruction.
      Wendell Hughes
      • Hughes W.L
      A new method for rebuilding a lower eyelid. Report of a case.
      described the tarsoconjunctival flap in 1937, which included a dissection and split of the tarsus and advancement from the upper eyelid. Maloof A et al.
      • Maloof A
      • Ng S
      • Leatherbarrow B
      The maximal Hughes procedure.
      reported the procedure used for extensive defects, anchoring the tarsoconjunctival flap to oblique medial and lateral periosteal flaps in the demand for stability, calling this the ‘The Maximal Hughes procedure’.
      The tarsoconjunctival flap is equally useful for subtotal or total defects involving the medial or lateral canthal tendons.
      The cheek rotation flap offers an alternative surgical approach for cutaneous cover, but a high complication rate has been reported with ectropion, entropion, and epiphora due to the cicatricial healing
      • Callahan M.A
      • Callahan A
      Mustarde flap lower lid reconstruction after malignancy.
      or accidental damage to the forehead branch of the facial nerve. The Hughes procedure tends to mechanically counteract the downward pull, seen with the cheek, or local transposition flap, as is seen with the surgical procedure used here, with a subcutaneous based nasolabial transposition flap.
      The advantages with the use of nasolabial flaps are the inconspicuous donor scar concealed in the nasolabial fold, and the reliable vascularity of the flap. In contrast to the cheek rotation flap, particularly in the male patient, the medial displacement of the hair-baring area is avoided by the use of nasolabial flaps.
      When the surgical defect is extensive after lower eyelid trauma, carcinoma, cicatricial secondary healing, congenital defects or sequelae, the nasolabial flap may be considered for eyelid reconstruction.

      References

        • Hughes W.L
        A new method for rebuilding a lower eyelid. Report of a case.
        Arch Ophthalmol. 1937; 17: 1008
        • Siegel R.J
        Palatal grafts for eyelid reconstruction.
        Plast Reconstr Surg. 1985; 76: 411-414
        • Nakajima H
        • Imanishi N
        • Aiso S
        Facial artery in the upper lip and nose: anatomy and a clinical application.
        Plast Reconstr Surg. 2002; 109: 855-861
        • Mustarde J.C
        Problems in eyelid reconstruction.
        Ann Ophthalmol. 1972; 4: 883-901
        • Koshima I
        • Urushibara K
        • Okuyama H
        • Moriguchi T
        Ear helix flap for reconstruction of total loss of the upper eyelid.
        Br J Plast Surg. 1999; 52: 314-316
        • Krastinova D
        • Franchi G
        • Kelly M.B
        • Chabolle F
        Rehabilitation of the paralysed or lax lower eyelid using a graft of conchal cartilage.
        Br J Plast Surg. 2002; 55: 12-19
        • Nakajima T
        • Yoshimura Y
        One-stage reconstruction of full-thickness lower eyelid defects using a subcutaneous pedicle flap lined by a palatal mucosal graft.
        Br J Plast Surg. 1996; 49: 183-186
        • Mustardé J.C
        Major reconstruction of the eyelid: function and aesthetics considerations.
        Clin Plast Surg. 1981; 8: 367
        • Porfiris E
        • Christopoulos A
        • Sandris P
        • Georgiou P
        • Ioannidis A
        • Popa C.V
        • Kalokerinos D
        Upper eyelid orbicularis oculi flap with tarsoconjunctival island for reconstruction of full-thickness lower lid defects.
        Plast Reconstr Surg. 1999; 103: 186-191
        • Furnas D.W
        • Furnas H
        Angular artery flap for total reconstruction of the lower eyelid.
        Ann Plast Surg. 1983; 10: 322-325
        • Dortzbach R.K
        • Hawes M.J
        Midline forehead flap in reconstructive procedures of the eyelids and exenterated socket.
        Ophthalmic Surg. 1981; 12: 257-268
        • Tenzel R.R
        Eyelid reconstruction by the semicircle flap technique.
        Ophthalmology. 1978; 85: 1164-1169
        • Maloof A
        • Ng S
        • Leatherbarrow B
        The maximal Hughes procedure.
        Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg. 2001; 17: 96-102
        • Callahan M.A
        • Callahan A
        Mustarde flap lower lid reconstruction after malignancy.
        Ophthalmology. 1980; 87: 279-286