Resource implications of bilateral autologous breast reconstruction – a single centre's seven year experience☆☆☆

Summary 

Introduction and aims

Since the recent introduction of ‘‘Payment by Results’’ as part of NHS financial reforms, it has been noted that there is an imbalance between allocated Healthcare Resource Group tariffs and actual resource use for certain procedures. This study was undertaken to assess the impression that bilateral breast reconstruction using autologous flaps is under-funded.

Material and methods

Patients who underwent bilateral flap breast reconstruction following mastectomy between 2000 and 2006 at Addenbrooke's University Hospital were identified. Resource cost analysis for each patient was based on the following parameters: number of operating consultants, theatre running costs, and length of hospital stay. The estimated hospital costs were then compared to the national tariff for the Healthcare Resource Group ‘‘Complex Breast Reconstruction using Flaps’’.

Key results

Over the 7-year period 24 patients underwent bilateral flap breast reconstruction (7 paired latissimus dorsi and 17 paired abdominal flaps). The mean operative time was 9.4h (£4.5/min), the mean hospital stay was 10 days (£150/day) and ten patients required 2 consultants (£34/h) operating. The average total cost equated to £5 492.

Conclusion

The allocated tariff of £4 053 is insufficient, even before the inclusion of hidden costs. Bilateral free flap breast reconstructions are grossly under-funded at present. With increasing financial pressures on NHS Trusts there may be a drive towards simpler operations, which receive proportionally greater remuneration.

Keywords: Breast reconstruction, NHS funding, Payment by Results, Patient choice, TRAM flap, DIEP flap